| Year | Name | Position | Honor |
| 2024 | Nigel Cheeks | RS | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2020 | Jonathan Forson | DB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2020 | Andrew Behm | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2019 | Caden Coulson | OL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2019 | Jacob Poetzl | DL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2018 | Ali Shockley | LB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2018 | Naeem Smith | DB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2017 | Ben Rooney | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2016 | Ryan Guthrie | LB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2016 | Louy Compton | DL | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2016 | Rob Castaneda | OL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2015 | David Goldsby | OL | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2015 | Jujuan Young-Battle | QB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2015 | Ryan Guthrie | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2014 | Tyrian Taylor | WR | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2013 | Corry O'Meally | DB | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2013 | Devante Averette | LB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2011 | Dexter Holmes | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2010 | John Rabe | TE | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2010 | Dexter Holmes | WR | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2010 | Willie Tindal | QB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2009 | Tirrell Rennie | QB | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2009 | Quintin Robinson | WR | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2009 | Aaron Strumski | DL | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2008 | Quintin Robinson | WR | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 2008 | Tirrell Rennie | WB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2008 | Joe Forgy | DL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2006 | Gerald Reed | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2006 | James Jones | DB | 3rd Team J.C.. Grid-Wire |
| 2005 | Joe Hall | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and 3rd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 2004 | Chance Jenkins | DB | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 2004 | Marcus Brooks | LB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 2003 | David Lonie | P | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 2000 | Mario Ivy | DL | 2nd Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1999 | Dwight Smith | DL | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1997 | Zack Smith | TE | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1996 | Jomone Fields | DE | 1st Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1996 | Kevious Clark | QB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1996 | Corey Willie | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1992 | Massillon Boyd | LB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1992 | Ghaton Ross | OL | 2nd Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1992 | Ken Duilio | DL | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1992 | Wade Wetlaufer | QB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1991 | Troy Hansen | OL | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1991 | Tony Teague | TE | 2nd Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1991 | Joe Allen | DE | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1990 | Arthur Davis | LB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1990 | Lance Keller | DL | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1989 | Bryan Thomsen | OL | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1989 | Eric Harris | DB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1989 | Eric Roberts | OL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1989 | Charles Miles | RB | Honorable Mention NJCAA J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1989 | Dale Carter | DB | Honorable Mention NJCAA J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1988 | Melvin Coleman | LB | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1988 | Jim Bodensteiner | OL | 2nd Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1988 | James Bradley | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA and 1st Team J.C Grid-Wire |
| 1987 | Greg Taylor | LB | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1987 | James Bradley | P | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1987 | Shawn Mattraw | OL | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1987 | James Vernon | DB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1987 | Jason Juhl | DB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1987 | Ulysses Bentley | RB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1986 | Darren Myles | RB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1986 | Brett Dirks | OL | 2nd Team J.C. Gride-Wire |
| 1986 | Carnell Washington | DL | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1986 | James Vernon | DB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1985 | Darren Tate | LB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1985 | Jackie Armstrong | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1985 | Toren Schonyers | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1984 | Kevin Ringer | RB | 2nd Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1984 | Myron Keppy | DL | 2nd Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1983 | Jerry Malone | OL | 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1983 | Mickey Hale | P | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1983 | Kendall Barz | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1983 | Mark Caballero | OL | Honorable Mention NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1982 | Mark Thomsen | QB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1981 | Don Wilson | DB | 1st Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1980 | Phil Montandon | P | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1980 | Frank Jacobs | RB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1980 | Julius Holt | DL | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1979 | Rick Anderson | K | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1979 | Brad Zumbach | P | 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1979 | Jim Pekar | DL | 2nd Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1979 | Tony Greene | RB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1979 | Dave Cayler | DB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1979 | Jeff Stevens | OL | Honorable Mention NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1978 | Todd Speer | P | Honorable Mention NJCAA J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1977 | Greg Smith | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1977 | Walter Grant | QB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1977 | Denny Wagner | C | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1976 | Darrell Hobbs | DL | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1976 | Reggie Hall | OL | 1st Team NJCAA and 1st Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1976 | Walter Grant | QB | Horable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention Grid-Wire |
| 1975 | Gary Evans | OL | 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1975 | Reddrick Williams | RB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1974 | Dave Green | DL | 1st Team NJCAA and 2nd Team J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1974 | John Blazek | K | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1973 | Mel Dunklin | E | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1973 | Walter Krebs | DL | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1972 | Emmitt Doolan | DB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1972 | Steve Craig | P | Honorable Mention J.c. Grid-Wire |
| 1972 | Bruce Barnes | WR | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1971 | Delbert Conners | DL | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1971 | Marty Smith | LB | 2nd Team NJCAA |
| 1971 | Don Willingham | RB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1970 | Bob Haydock | C | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1969 | Jim Hinton | DB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1969 | Tom Surlas | LB | Honorable Mention NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1968 | Mike Palmer | HB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1968 | Steve Hornung | LB | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1968 | Ken Scott | G | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1968 | Mike Todd | LB | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1967 | Stan Whitman | C | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1967 | Mike Palmer | HB | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1966 | Marv Johnson | E | 2nd Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention |
| 1966 | Bob Hampton | G | Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1965 | Bill Smith | HB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1964 | John Lawson | E | 1st Team NJCAA |
| 1963 | Bob Wilcinski | FB | 1st Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1963 | Jim Growden | C | 2nd Team NJCAA and Honorable Mention J.C. Grid-Wire |
| 1963 | Jim Murra | DL | Honorable Mention NJCAA |
| 1962 | Dan Patterson | E | Honorable Mention NJCAA |